The Preferred Flower

The Preferred Flower: Paintings by Mabel Loomis Todd

November 10 – December 30, 2026

Writer, editor, lecturer, traveler, conservationist and artist, Mabel Loomis Todd (1856–1932) exercised her agile curiosity across the fields of literature, science, nature, and the visual arts. Best known today for her influential role in bringing the poetry of Emily Dickinson to the public, Todd also pursued creative work of her own. Her oil paintings of wildflowers offer an intimate glimpse into an artistic habit of a lifetime. Small in scale, these works invite close looking and become occasions for studying color, form, texture, and the distinctive character of individual plants. 

In Amherst, Mabel Todd found a lively intellectual community and a vivid inspiring natural landscape. Her contributions to the town included founding roles with the Amherst Historical Society, the Amherst Woman’s Club, and the local chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution. 

Todd became closely connected with the Dickinson family as a friend of Emily’s sister Lavinia and romantic partner of her brother Austin. Although she and Dickinson never met face to face, their correspondence centered on a shared interest in the floral world. Todd chose Monotropa uniflora, “Indian Pipes,” as the subject of a painting for the poet she called “a genius.” Dickinson gratefully replied “That without suspecting it you should send me the preferred flower of life, seems almost supernatural….”

The collection of eighteen paintings were acquired as a set by Ruth Owen Jones, Amherst historian and longtime guide at the Emily Dickinson Museum, whose family gifted them to the Museum in 2026. The paintings date from 1876 when Mabel Todd studied at the New England Conservatory in Boston to 1886 when the Todds resided in Amherst. 

The Amherst History Center combines botanical paintings and decorative items to reveal Mabel Loomis Todd’s love of local plant life and her trained eye as an amateur botanist. Many of the paintings in this display were done in Hampton, New Hampshire, likely during the summers that Mabel Loomis, her mother, and grandmother spent in New England to avoid the heat in Washington, D.C. Her father Eben Loomis, a professional mathematician and lifelong naturalist, encouraged her to look for details in the plants that they found as they explored nature together.  

Mrs. Todd’s daughter Millicent later recalled, “The accuracy of her work can be judged by the fact that her painting of milkweed with monarch butterflies was used by Samuel Scudder as a cover design for his 12-volume work on the butterflies of New England.” 

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection, Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection,

Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.

In 1882 Mabel Todd met the artist Martin Johnson Heade, a friend of her father and a prolific painter of landscapes and still life flowers, including flowers on velvet in a romantic style. He became an artistic mentor and assisted her in expanding her work beyond wood and canvas to painting on clothing. Her exposure to the imagery of Martin Heade’s flowers may have helped Todd recognize the genius of Emily Dickinson’s poetic imagery. She extended her decorative painting to work on ceramics and brass.  When David and Mabel Todd moved into their first home, The Dell, Mabel created a frieze in a floral design to decorate the walls.   

From 1884 to 1894. Mabel Todd shared her love of art by giving painting lessons at Mrs. Mary E. Stearns School for young girls (known as The Convent) which was held in the President’s House at Amherst College.  Todd continued her support for the arts throughout her time in Amherst by creating decorations for college and social events, organizing amateur art exhibitions, and judging the Fine Arts at the September Cattle Show. 

Lady's Slipper Orchid

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection, Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.

Decorative Hanging

1885, Silk Velvet

Amherst Historical Society and Museum Collection, 2010.0002.17

Scarlet Lily

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection, Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.

Plate with marigolds, nasturtiums and asters

1883,  Papier-mâché

Amherst Historical Society and Museum Collection

Seaside Goldenrods

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection, Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.

Standing screen with tobacco, squash and broom corn

1884, Wooden frame with oil on canvas panels

Amherst Historical Society and Museum Collection, 1973.0226

Daffodil

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection, Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.

Pussy Willows

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection, Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.

Tray with Lilies

c. 1875-1900, Wood

Amherst Historical Society and Museum Collection, 1973.0975

Jonquil

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection, Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.

Standing 4 panel screen with pokeweed, mullein, burdock and heliopsis

c. 1884, Wooden frame with oil on canvas panels

Amherst Historical Society and Museum Collection, 2010.0002.24

Pickerel Weed

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection, Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.

Plate with iris

1886, Porcelain

Amherst Historical Society and Museum Collection, 1973.0592.03

Loosestrife

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection, Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.

Plate with scarlet sage

c. 1875-1900, Stoneware

Amherst Historical Society and Museum Collection, 2010.0002.12

Ilex Verticulata

Emily Dickinson Museum Collection, Gift of Ruth Owen Jones.